Crest 3D White Strips vs Colgate Whitening Pen

Did you know that 86% of people believe that a white, bright smile can boost their confidence and attractiveness? If you’re looking to enhance your smile, you’ve probably come across two popular at-home teeth whitening options – Crest 3D White Strips and Colgate Whitening Pen. But which one is the right choice for you? In this article, we will compare these products in detail to help you make an informed decision and achieve the whiter teeth you desire.

Whitening Pens vs. Whitening Strips: Treatment Overviews

Crest 3D Whitestrips Professional Effects

Crest 3D Whitestrips Professional Effects

  • 20 Levels Whiter in just 22 days
  • #1 Dentist recommended at-home teeth whitening brand
  • Uses the same whitening ingredient as dentists
  • Enamel Safe & Effective
Check Price
Colgate Optic White Teeth Whitening Pen

Colgate Optic White Teeth Whitening Pen

  • Get 2 Colgate Optic White Teeth Whitening Pens for quick results.
  • Overnight Whitening Pen with precise brush and easy-click top for gel control.
  • Apply onto dry teeth before bed, then brush in the morning for a brighter smile.
  • Removes years of stains in just 1 week with enamel-safe formula.
  • Provides 35 nightly uses without sensitivity.
Check Price

When it comes to at-home teeth whitening options, Crest 3D White Strips and Colgate Whitening Pen are two popular choices. In this section, we will provide an overview of these products to help you decide which one suits your needs.

Whitening Pens

Whitening pens are gel-based products that come with a brush tip for easy application. They are designed to be applied directly to the teeth, allowing you to target specific areas or stains. The gel contains a whitening agent that helps remove surface stains and brightens your smile. The convenience of the brush tip makes it a preferred choice for many users.

Whitening Strips

On the other hand, whitening strips are adhesive strips coated with a whitening agent. They are easy to apply and adhere to the surface of your teeth. The strips are designed to cover the front teeth, ensuring a consistent and even application of the whitening agent. The adhesive nature of the strips allows you to continue with your daily activities while the product works its magic.

Both whitening pens and strips offer affordable, easy-to-use solutions for at-home teeth whitening. They are widely available and can be purchased over-the-counter or online. However, they differ in terms of application method and duration of use, which may impact your decision based on personal preference and convenience.

Effectiveness Comparison

When considering which teeth whitening method to choose between Crest and Colgate, it’s essential to assess the effectiveness of each option. While both whitening pens and strips can effectively whiten teeth, they do have their limitations.

Whitening Pens

Whitening pens are a convenient and portable option for on-the-go touch-ups. However, they typically whiten teeth by about three shades on average. The pen applicator allows for precise targeting of stained areas, but it may not provide the same level of coverage as strips.

Whitening Strips

Whitening strips, on the other hand, are adhesive strips coated with a whitening agent. They can cover a larger surface area of the teeth, resulting in more uniform whitening. Strips have the potential to whiten teeth by an average of 5–7 shades, making them a more powerful option compared to pens.

 Crest Whitening PenColgate Whitening Strips
EffectivenessWhitens teeth by approximately 3 shadesWhitens teeth by 5–7 shades on average
Application MethodBrush-on gel formulaAdhesive strips
EnhancementSome brands offer LED lights to boost effectivenessN/A
Professional-Level WhiteningNoNo

It’s important to note that while both methods can provide noticeable whitening results, they are not equivalent to professional in-office treatments. Managing expectations and understanding the limitations of at-home products is crucial for a satisfying experience.

What Can It Treat?

Whitening pens and strips are popular at-home teeth whitening options that are designed to remove surface stains and provide touch-ups after a professional whitening session. When used according to the instructions, these products can effectively whiten your teeth by several shades.

However, it’s important to note that whitening strips may not be as effective for individuals with crooked or misaligned teeth. The adhesive strips need to come into direct contact with the tooth surfaces to work effectively, and misaligned teeth may prevent proper contact.

Overall, both whitening pens and strips can be effective in improving the color and appearance of your teeth, but it’s essential to consider your individual dental situation and consult with your dentist before deciding on the best option for you.

How White Will My Teeth Get?

When comparing the effectiveness of whitening pens and strips, it’s important to consider the expected results. While both options can help whiten your teeth, the degree of whitening may vary.

Whitening pens, although convenient to use, are generally not as effective as other methods. This is because there’s nothing to hold the whitening agent to the tooth surface, limiting its contact and effectiveness. As a result, the results may take a few weeks to become noticeable and may require regular touch-ups to maintain the desired level of whiteness.

On the other hand, whitening strips have been found to be more effective in delivering noticeable results. On average, they can whiten teeth by 5-7 shades. With consistent use, you can expect to see improvements in as little as 1 to 2 weeks. For enhanced whitening, some whitening strip brands also utilize LED lights to boost the effectiveness of the whitening process.

Whitening Pens vs. Whitening Strips – Effectiveness Comparison

ProductEffectivenessExpected ResultsAdditional Features
Crest 3D White Strips5-7 shades (on average)Visible results in 1-2 weeksLED light technology for enhanced whitening
Colgate Whitening Pen3 shades (on average)Gradual results over a few weeksN/A

Affordability Comparison

When it comes to at-home teeth whitening, affordability is an important factor to consider. Both whitening pens and strips offer cost-effective options for achieving a brighter smile. Prices can vary depending on the brand and the number of applications or strips included in each package.

Whitening pens typically range from $8 to $30, offering a budget-friendly option for those looking to brighten their teeth. These pens often come with multiple applications, allowing you to achieve lasting results without breaking the bank.

On the other hand, whitening strips generally fall in the price range of $20 to $50. While they may be slightly more expensive compared to whitening pens, they often provide a larger quantity of strips for multiple treatments. This can make them more cost-effective in the long run.

Ultimately, the value of the product can be determined by considering the cost per treatment. It’s important to choose a teeth whitening option that fits within your budget while still providing the desired results.

Affordability Comparison Summary:

Whitening MethodPrice Range (USD)Number of Applications/StripsCost per Treatment
Whitening Pens$8 – $30Multiple applicationsVaries
Whitening Strips$20 – $50Multiple stripsVaries

Quality of Ingredients

When comparing Crest 3D White Strips and Colgate Whitening Pen, it’s essential to consider the quality of ingredients used in each product. Both whitening pens and strips typically utilize hydrogen peroxide or carbamide peroxide as the active whitening agent. These ingredients work effectively by breaking down the stains on the surface of your teeth, revealing a whiter smile.

In addition to the active whitening agents, some products may incorporate other ingredients to enhance the whitening process. For instance, PAP (phthalimido peroxy caproic acid) is often included to reduce sensitivity commonly associated with teeth whitening. PVP (polyvinylpyrrolidone) may also be present in some formulas to prevent new stains from forming, while flavoring agents are used to enhance the overall taste.

When choosing a teeth whitening product, it’s crucial to opt for a reputable brand that prioritizes the quality of its ingredients. By selecting a trusted brand, you can have confidence in the effectiveness and safety of the whitening treatment.

Comparison of Ingredients:

ProductActive Whitening AgentAdditional Ingredients
Crest 3D White StripsHydrogen Peroxide or Carbamide PeroxidePAP, PVP, Flavoring Agents
Colgate Whitening PenHydrogen Peroxide or Carbamide PeroxidePAP, PVP, Flavoring Agents

Convenience Comparison

When it comes to convenience, both whitening pens and strips offer hassle-free application that fits seamlessly into your daily routine. Let’s take a closer look at the advantages of each method:

Whitening Pens

Whitening pens provide a straightforward and user-friendly application process. You can apply the whitening gel directly to your teeth using the brush tip, targeting the areas you want to whiten. Pens require minimal clean-up and typically dissolve over time, eliminating the need for rinsing or removal. This makes them especially convenient for on-the-go touch-ups or quick whitening sessions.

Whitening Strips

Whitening strips offer a disposable and mess-free solution. Applying the adhesive strips to your teeth ensures even distribution of the whitening agent. Strips need to be worn for the specified time, typically ranging from 15 to 30 minutes, allowing the whitening ingredients to work their magic. Once the time is up, simply remove the strips and discard them. However, it’s worth noting that strips may initially restrict speech until you get accustomed to wearing them.

When choosing between whitening pens and strips, consider your preferences and lifestyle. If you prefer a direct and convenient application method without the need for removal, pens may be the ideal choice for you. On the other hand, if you appreciate the simplicity and ease of disposable strips, they can be a convenient option. It’s important to select the method that aligns best with your individual needs and preferences.

Convenience ComparisonWhitening PensWhitening Strips
Application ProcessDirect application with brush tipAdhesive strips
Clean-UpMinimal clean-up; pens dissolve over timeStrips are disposable
Speech RestrictionNo speech restrictionMay restrict speech initially

Treatment Time and Clean-Up

When it comes to at-home teeth whitening, treatment time and clean-up are important factors to consider. The duration of treatment for whitening pens and strips can vary depending on the product and the severity of stains. Whitening pens typically offer shorter treatment times, allowing you to apply the gel for a few minutes and go about your day. On the other hand, whitening strips require wearing them for 15 to 30 minutes per session to achieve the desired results.

As for clean-up, both methods offer relative simplicity. Whitening pens often dissolve over time, eliminating the need for any specific clean-up steps. However, it’s advisable to rinse your mouth thoroughly to remove any residue. Whitening strips, on the other hand, are disposable and can be removed and discarded after each session. This makes clean-up hassle-free and convenient.

For optimal results and to maintain good oral hygiene, it is crucial to follow the instructions provided with each product. Pay attention to the recommended treatment duration and frequency, as well as any specific clean-up or aftercare recommendations. This will ensure that you get the best possible results while keeping your teeth and gums healthy.

Hey there! Dr. Husam Alhurani (DDS) here! 👋

Ready for monthly doses of dental awesomeness? Sign up now and let's keep those smiles shining!

Scroll to Top